PDA

View Full Version : Tough Call: Dilemma on Amber Alerts


Roamer
04-03-2008, 09:59 AM
http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=4576301&page=1

Dilemma of an Amber Alert

Authorities Struggle to Balance Need for Amber Alerts With Their Possible Overuse
By EMILY FRIEDMAN
April 3, 2008

When 15 hours had passed since 7-year-old Hser Nay Moo vanished outside her family's Salt Lake City apartment, volunteers who had been tirelessly searching for the young girl began to question why local authorities had yet to issue an Amber Alert.

A lack of evidence, according to the police chief, and the distinct possibility that Moo was with friends and had not actually been abducted delayed the use of the alert system, which authorities can use to inform the public about missing children by interrupting television and radio programs and displaying the information on electronic highway signs.

"If I issue it later, people would say, 'Why did you wait so long?'" South Salt Lake Police Chief Chris Snyder told The Salt Lake Tribune. "If I issue it earlier, it's a case of 'Is it being abused? Is it being issued properly?'"

"From my standpoint, it is [being used properly]," Snyder told the paper. "I'm not taking any chances."

The dilemma Snyder faced is common for law enforcement officials, several of whom told ABCNEWS.com that they often found themselves torn between activating Amber Alerts and holding off, taking time to ensure the child was actually abducted and not just a runaway, and thereby preventing the overuse of the system.

"Issuing an Amber Alert is one of the toughest decisions you make as a law enforcement official," said Terrant County Sheriff Dee Anderson, who pioneered the Amber Alert System after 9-year-old Amber Hagerman was abducted from her Houston neighborhood and killed in 1996. "It's a huge responsibility."

Officials Forced to Stand up to Media, Parental Pressure

"The plan is a victim of its own success," Anderson said. "The more children we recover the more popular it becomes. People think it's the magic bullet to recover missing children."

Before issuing Amber Alerts, authorities must meet several criteria, and although they vary from state to state, their decisions hinge on the same basic principles. The missing child must be younger than 18 and believed to be in imminent danger. Officials must also have information such as a car model or a description of the abductor to provide in the alert, and authorities must be certain that the child has been abducted by a stranger (in some states this provision is extended to include family members).

Battnt
04-03-2008, 10:04 AM
IMO...Due to her age, it should have been issued right away....

Battnt
04-03-2008, 10:07 AM
I'm also disturbed by the comment...She might have been with friends...Why the heck couldnt they have checked that out ASAP?...I dont get it....

Cat
04-03-2008, 10:18 AM
I agree, that is really sad.

Roamer
04-03-2008, 10:26 AM
I agree. If she'd been with friends, the parents of those friends would have called someone. I think they waited too long on her case to issue the alert.

Tracian
04-08-2008, 06:54 PM
Error should be in favor of the child's safety. I don't think likewise, that they should issue if it is a parental abduction.

How many cases have we all read that sometimes parents abduct and kill there own children; One in particular, the mother searched for a very long time to find the bodies of her children, as her ex-husband killed them and then killed himself, once caught.

I think that it is impossible to abuse the Amber Alert system, I don't care what age a person is, they have loved ones, parents, children, friends, and a community that is scarred forever when someone is ruthlessly ripped away.

Even a 'runaway' is a high risk for rape and murder.

Amber Alerts should be used for anyone missing.

animallady
06-18-2008, 01:37 AM
Error should be in favor of the child's safety. I don't think likewise, that they should issue if it is a parental abduction.

How many cases have we all read that sometimes parents abduct and kill there own children; One in particular, the mother searched for a very long time to find the bodies of her children, as her ex-husband killed them and then killed himself, once caught.

I think that it is impossible to abuse the Amber Alert system, I don't care what age a person is, they have loved ones, parents, children, friends, and a community that is scarred forever when someone is ruthlessly ripped away.

Even a 'runaway' is a high risk for rape and murder.

Amber Alerts should be used for anyone missing.


Well said. ITA! When it comes to our children, always err on the side of caution.

DestinySearchOps
07-03-2008, 02:54 AM
Ok, I will first give some information from the Hser Nay Moon case. Destiny Search Project was notified of the missing child at 9:45 PM. This was only 2 hours and 45 minutes after the police first were on scene. The Media was all notified at that same time. The missing girl led off all the local top stories, and also had radio mentions that night (with out any Amber Alert) Now should the Amber Alert been issued the next morning earlier? possibly. We all were hoping through out the night that she would show up to school at 8:30 that morning. After that did not happen the police all had to meet and determine the next action. The Amber Alert was triggered not much afterwards.

Now keep in mind this story already was leading every news cast, on the radio, and we also had a fully operational search that had been running all night. A Amber Alert in this case would not have gotten any more volunteers or news coverage then what we were already getting.

My personal feeling is that Amber Alerts do need to be saved for the most pressing cases where we have solid information that will assist in finding the missing person. My biggest fear is that the Amber Alert, which is a amazing program will be over used to the point its not paid attention too. Think of this... when is the last time you heard a car alarm and did anything? Once a alarm is triggered so many times, and some of the times falsely then people start to ignore it. Its the old 'Boy who cried wolf' syndrome.

Keep in mind that the Amber Alert may be the most public notice, but many other things are out besides the Amber Plan. Destiny Search recently was added to the Missing Endangered Persons bulletin, we now receive updates 2-3 times a week of missing persons. The media also gets these notifications. All law Enforcement have access to Missing Persons information, and are sent alerts all the time.

I know that we all are here on this board because we have huge hearts and want to help. Keep in mind though that systems are in place to that means.

awakening2lite
07-07-2008, 01:30 PM
I was under the impression the Amber Alert was issued once they had a vehicle description and/or tag number. Is that still the case?

Where I live the interstate hwys have overhead lighted info boards that give the people on the highway information to be on the look out for the Amber Alert vehicle thought to be in the area.

I don't see how a missing child case could ever abuse a system designed to help them be returned home.

And speaking of runaways, how many runaways are actually runaways? How can we know they haven't been coerced into leaving with a predator, or abducted after leaving home? So many of them are never found. It's my believe if a persons whereabouts are unknown they are a missing person.

animallady
07-09-2008, 09:55 AM
<snipped>
I don't see how a missing child case could ever abuse a system designed to help them be returned home.

And speaking of runaways, how many runaways are actually runaways? How can we know they haven't been coerced into leaving with a predator, or abducted after leaving home? So many of them are never found. It's my believe if a persons whereabouts are unknown they are a missing person.


ITA. I TOTALLY AGREE!!!

:1222423: For All of Those Who are Discounted

CynthiaMackMOM
04-22-2009, 02:47 PM
Think about this twist. My daughter has a psychological issue. It creats radical behaviors. She got into a vehicle. There was a witness. However since she left a note she was not deemed in need. BUT think about this. Nobody knows the vehicle, or the driver! No one knows which way they headed, nothing.

She left on purpose, but that does NOT mean she is not in harms way! It is my opinion with known unstable kids that should be taken into the equasion. They will get in with people they do not know well, etc...

Deb